Zoe ([info]zcme) wrote in [info]nolose,

nolose = social contagion?

apparently, coming to places like nolose and befriending other fabulous fatties can make you fatter!  so, says Dr. Christakis of Harvard whose recent study was just written up in the New York Times.

Dr. Nicholas Christakis, a physician and professor of medical sociology at Harvard Medical School and a principal investigator in the new study, says one explanation is that friends affect each others’ perception of fatness. When a close friend becomes obese, obesity may not look so bad.

“You change your idea of what is an acceptable body type by looking at the people around you,” Dr. Christakis said.

The investigators say their findings can help explain why Americans have become fatter in recent years — each person who became obese was likely to drag some friends with them

i'll be curious to read the whole article.  i know a little of the work he did with Chang on medical modeling of obesity which was a really interesting account of how, at the conceptual level and within medical textbooks, definitions of obesity shifted over time.  They argued that this illustrated how seemingly cohesive phenomena are in fact mutable, produced within social and historical contexts, and undergo considerable transformation over time with significant ontological consequences

but this?

If the new research is correct, it may mean that something in the environment seeded what many call an obesity epidemic, leading a few people to gain weight. Then social networks let the obesity spread rapidly.

It also may mean that the way to avoid becoming fat is to avoid having fat friends.

That is not the message they meant to convey, say the study investigators, Dr. Christakis and his colleague, James Fowler, an associate professor of political science at the University of California in San Diego.

You don’t want to lose a friend who becomes obese, Dr. Christakis said. Friends are good for your overall health, he explains. So why not make friends with a thin person, he suggests, and let the thin person’s behavior influence you and your obese friend?

this makes me a little less excited about Dr. Christakis' work. 


and Dr. Kelly Brownell stands up for fatties!  although his work is ultimately all about reducing obesity, he is a leading academic figure looking at fat discrimination.  Brownell does do some interesting work on how corporate practices have contributed to rising obesity rates too.

“I think there’s a great risk here in blaming obese people even more for things that are caused by a terrible environment,” Dr. Brownell said.

anyway, read the whole article.

nerdily and chubbily signing off,
xoxo,
Zoe

  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 9 comments

[info]giniliz

July 26 2007, 02:00:06 UTC 4 years ago

I've seen the actual report on this study and it is the more ridiculous piece of "science" I've read so far this year, a perfectly pure example of just how far people will go to jump on the anti-obesity funding bandwagon. It was a big time data dredge and rather unusual statistical methods. And the general conclusions were, as you mentioned, that we all need to befriend thin people. It ends with the suggestion that "the psychosocial mechanisms of the spread of obesity may rely less on behavioral imitation than on a change in an ego's general perception of the social norms regarding the acceptability of obesity." -- a possibility I find beautiful and hopeful, but the researchers find problematic.

I'd be happy to forward the report to anybody interested. LJname at yahoo.com.

[info]zcme

July 26 2007, 02:25:06 UTC 4 years ago

a possibility I find beautiful and hopeful, but the researchers find problematic

exactly. someone on [info]fatshionista was saying that perhaps it's that individuals tend to befriend those with similar interests and that behavior (going out to eat, eating rich foods, whatever) might make that social network of friends all more likely to gain weight.

for me, i don't choose friends because they're fat. but being fat positive and having some fat activist politics is pretty much a prerequisite for being my friend. at least having an open mind and being willing to consider it!

and lo and behold, many of the folks who fit this category are other fat activists who have reframed fatness in positive ways for themselves as well! truly shocking.

anyway, i'd love a copy. can you email me at this username + yahoo? thanks!

[info]giniliz

July 26 2007, 02:40:07 UTC 4 years ago

Will send.

And another thing they didn't consider is that we tend to befriend those from similar SES and ethnic (obvious and not-so-obvious) backgrounds, so we do share factors other than what we eat with our friends.

[info]mitchellatticus

July 26 2007, 04:42:27 UTC 4 years ago

I think i got fatter reading this post.
xoxo

[info]zcme

July 26 2007, 12:26:04 UTC 4 years ago

i suspected you might as i embedded subliminal pictures of cupcakes in this post... bwah!

Anonymous

July 29 2007, 15:15:44 UTC 4 years ago

Academic figures leading the fight against weight discrimination

In mentioning Dr. Brownell, please don't overlook the work of Dr. Rebecca Puhl, http://ruddsoundbites.typepad.com/photos/authors/rebecca.html

also at the Rudd Center. She posts many excellent articles on the topic of weight bias. Well worth reading.

[info]zcme

July 29 2007, 19:29:56 UTC 4 years ago

Re: Academic figures leading the fight against weight discrimination

oh yes, they often publish together. i was just citing him specifically as he was quoted in this article.

[info]queen_bbb

February 19 2008, 02:01:34 UTC 4 years ago

Your icon picture here is a hot one, Z.

[info]zcme

February 19 2008, 02:22:18 UTC 4 years ago

thanks BMoney! lol.
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…